How Does an Abused Woman Experience a Patriarchal God? (by Kathleen Schwab)

abused woman

In the evangelical churches of my young adulthood God was considered a man.

I was told this many times by pastors and by lay-Christians, men and women alike. Even a New Testament professor of mine from my liberal arts college (who was once a pastor of a liberal denomination) told us one day in class, “I mean no disrespect to women, but God is described as a Father and there are ways that men embody the image of God that women simply can’t.”

Interestingly enough, I went to a woman’s college and so this pronouncement was made to a class of young women. No one argued of course, not even the declared feminists. He was the authority.

Now think about this: According to the CDC, close to 25% of women experience physical assault by a romantic partner. Many of these women have children who internalize early that male violence to loved ones is normal. 1 in 5 women are sexually assaulted at some point in their lives. (This is a conservative estimate – I think it is higher.)

How does insisting on the masculinity of God affect girls and women like me who experienced both domestic violence and sexual assault before even beginning Kindergarten?

I can tell you how God worked with the realities of my life to reach me (and the realities were not good). My extended family includes a man who broke a woman’s shoulder and knocked out her teeth, a man who stabbed a woman over two-hundred times, and a man who beat a woman in the face, threw her down a flight of stairs, and strangled her.

I didn’t think of these things as strange or “the exception to the rule;” I thought of them as part of life.

We looked like an average suburban family and perhaps we were. I heard plenty of things from other kids that matched my own experiences. The women in my family talked among themselves in “hushed” voices about bruises covered with make-up and about their latest hospital visits. They warned me in quiet voices about things to avoid and they remained outwardly deferential to men.

So how could God reach me to convince me of good intentions? The church that I knew was sure that God was a man; well, I experienced men as powerful and dangerous people who nonetheless had to be placated.

In my case, the first way was a powerful dream that I had when I was 14-years-old. In the dream I was in my childhood home and the sense of danger became more and more desperate. I knew I had to escape, but, afraid to leave home alone, I tried to convince someone to come with me. All of my friends said “no.”

Eventually, I set out alone. Once away from home, my childhood hero Harriet Tubman appeared in front of me. I knew she was Harriet Tubman, famous conductor on the Underground Railroad, the “Moses” who led hundreds of slaves to freedom, and here she was to help me.

In my dream Harriet Tubman was young, ageless really, tall and athletic, with form fitting 1970’s clothes, a big afro, and a fierce, stunningly beautiful face. She told me I could come with her if I wanted, and she would lead me and others to freedom. The dream ended with me in the center of a group of other people, running through a cityscape of twisting alleys, following hard after our leader.

The dream symbolized a few things. It mirrored the fact that after leaving home at age 14, I felt essentially alone in the world and I knew the “1970’s Harriet Tubman figure” represented God, who met me soon after I made the break with my old life.

The woman in my dream was unrushed with the stillness of great strength, but I also saw that she was ferocious. Under her wing I would be safe forever. And the way she made her offer – that I could join her if I chose – welcomed me into the adult-world. This was my decision and my choice and that had a power of its own. I saw I would belong to her (and to this community of her people) with a new kind of depth.

At the time I accepted the dream for the guidance it gave me. Later I understood that I was able to successfully receive all of this – the fierceness and strength of God and the respect of God for my choice and my personhood – because God showed up as a woman.

Male ferocity would have driven me back into my shell. I couldn’t take an offer of respect and autonomy from a man seriously. In my experience, men made these offers to girls and women, but took them back just as quickly if they didn’t like what the girl or woman did with her freedom.

Another way God reached and healed me was as a man. When I decided to dedicate my life to God, I thought immediately of Jesus, who I had learned about growing up. I began talking to Him and reading the four Gospels.

Jesus may not do this with everyone, but He came to me with a distinctly masculine energy; I spent my prayer times absorbed in His love, His care, His lightness of heart. He was afraid of nothing: He owned the world.

He accepted and loved me unconditionally and had all the time in the world for me. No therapist or program could have accomplished what Jesus did by simply being with me. He began to heal my relationship with men. Because He radiated safety, I began to see that I could be safe with some men.

Jesus was kind; He was safe; He was on my side. I know I am not the only woman traumatized by male violence and healed by the Perfect Man. Jesus’ redeems all of humanity, but I think that when He chooses to, He can use His masculine aspect to redeem human men not only for heaven and eternity, but in the hearts of women here and now.

Jesus can be the example of what men are created to be, what Adam was in garden prior to “the fall”, and what they still can be with Christ’s help. Jesus can set men free from violence and He can set women free from the damage male violence does to their hearts, minds, and bodies.

Genesis 1:28 says, “So God created humankind in His own image, in the image of God He created them; male and female He created them.” I don’t think God is male and female in the way that human beings are, but both masculinity and femininity can express aspects of God’s nature (especially in specific circumstances in our lives).

I experienced God as a fierce woman and as a nurturing man; both flip the usual script of our culture, but those experiences opened my eyes to seeing God in more ways. 

kportrait

Kathleen Schwab is a lifelong lover of God, a literature teacher, a wife and mother. She is a co-author (along with Therese Kay) of “Messages from God: An Illuminated Devotional,” which is a five week devotional inspired by the synergy of words and art in medieval illuminated manuscripts. Find this Devotional on Amazon here.

More from Jory Micah

Southern California, I’m Coming Your Way #CoffeeTour

Hey friends! My husband and I have been traveling all over the...
Read More

9 Comments

  • i can understand what your saying about Abuse ..BUT very big but is .should clearly state
    NOT ALL MEN ARE LIKE THAT..i, was abused .by different adults .NO WAY AM I LIKE THAT .
    i am disabled have m.e . long list health issues .my story of abuse is in a Authors book
    i do a blog,http;//mark-kent.webs.com

  • Mark – What I hear you saying is that being blamed for something you did not do is not fair. That is true; it isn’t fair. Ending up carrying responsibility for what other people do is not fair, but it is a feature of our world works.

    Children don’t relate to their parents as two individuals; a child experiences Mom and Dad as an archetype of masculinity and an archetype of femininity. The child experiences the parents’ marriage as a blueprint for intimate relationships. This is really an unfair burden to place on mom and dad, who are really just two individuals with their own problems, but that is reality. We all carry more responsibility in the world than is fair to us.

    I would ask you to consider this: in the above post, I described experiencing intense male violence, including a particularly brutal murder. (200 stab wounds. How much anger is behind an act like that? Do you think the men I grew up around were calm other than when they did things like that, or did I grow up in a stew of simmering male rage?) The first response I received is from a man, and it includes two statements in all caps, the equivalent of shouting. I talked about male violence towards women, and very quickly I had a man shout at me, correcting me, and telling me I am not talking about men the right way. Can you see that your post fits right in to what I learned as a child, that “men are powerful and dangerous people who nonetheless have to be placated”?

    I really struggle to understand the priorities in your post. Your major concern with my story is that men might feel badly when a woman talks about what happened to her? Why is how a man feels the most important thing? Why is the number or girls and women physically harmed not of greater concern?

    When women talk about the reality of what they suffer at the hands of men, I am finding that men push back hard and fast. They get angry and insulted by women’s stories, and The result has been that women keep quiet, because the price is high. You wrote to establish your innocence. I ask you to consider that what you said, and the way you said it, places you in support of the cause of the abusers, not the cause of the victims.

  • This reminds me a bit of the book, The Shack, by Paul Young in which God appeared as an African American woman. I was stunned when my pastor told me that some people hated the book for just that fact – it offended their sensibilities that God could appear as a woman, never mind an African-American one. I think God is beyond gender and beyond race, and as discussed in a recent post on Facebook, beyond political affiliation. God is God is God – our loving savior – male, female, eagle, deer, soft voice…however God chooses to appear to us, Her creation, it is still God and She loves us fiercely and tenderly.

    • I heard about some people being very unhappy about God being presented as a black woman. I also had an atheist friend say that maybe she would read The Shack, after she heard about a black woman representing God. It is the sort of thing that can intrigue those outside Christianity – and that makes it a good thing I think!
      Also, I want to get a tee shirt that says ‘I thought God was a black woman before it was cool.” Bet I could put that on Etsy 🙂

  • Excellent post on the problems of male dominance (including male violence). NZ of course has problems with marital violence, like many other countries. However we are used to women in high political positions. Currently the top three positions are held by women: – Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern, Chief Justice Dame Sian Elias and Governor-General Dame Patsy Reddy. These are role models for the next generation of leaders.

    • I think women in positions of political power will flip the script, among other reasons because they see the problem from a different angle. Iceland has had many women in top positions for the past few decades, and they have the highest gender equality in the world. Something that I think is important is that once gender equality is accepted, men report more happiness with the system. (I am basing this on interviews with Icelandic men, who report being in favor of equal pay because ‘It only makes sense. And if the wife makes more money, then the family has more money.’ So practical!)
      I think more equality of any sort – gender, racial, social class – eases the stresses of a hierarchical society, and everyone breathes a sigh of relief.

  • Kathleen, I grew up in a fatherless home. My first experience with a boyfriend was physically abusive. I froze and panicked when any man became frustrated for any reason. I was in my thirties when a guest speaker at my church, a Hebrew professor, said that in Hebrew and Aramaic the Holy Spirit is female. I learned that the first century church in Jerusalem referred to Her as Mother God or God the Mother. I began to heal. I began to gather strength. I began to see Her hand in so much of my life.
    The Holy Spirit didn’t become male until the scriptures were translated into Latin, and the Catholic Church embraced Her as male.
    I think the abuse of women would lesson if the church acknowledged that it is led by a female Spirit.
    Another thing I learned that changed how I saw God was learning that the word we translate as God is Elohim, a Hebrew word that is not only plural, but a combination of two words for God, El (m.) and Elohah (f.). God is both masculine and feminine.
    For me and others like me, this is powerful, life changing knowledge.

  • Cheryel-

    That is such fascinating information about gender in the original languages.

    I agree with you that abuse of women in the church would not happen, or not to the extent that it does, if God were perceived as female. I think that when Christians see God as a male father, a male son, and a possibly male/neuter spirit, women become outsiders in churches. Men can be comfortable discounting women’s experiences and opinions, because men see themselves as the center, and woman as something ‘other.’

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *